four rich kids on a yacht encounter some pirates. a shark and a horrifyingly tortured and raped corpse make surprise appearances.
the kids and the remaining pirate find a beautiful and mysterious island. and so our tale truly begins...
this book is vile. if you like vile, you should read this book. I highly recommend it!
if you like the human body - and other sorts of bodies - to be viewed as pieces of meat to be fucked with, carcasses-to-be, then this is also your book. have fun with it!
there are surely some books that get written just to see if they could, well, be written. not to play with language or share ideas or tell a good story or scare you or amuse you or excite you or take you to a different place. books that exist just because. I haven't come across many books like that but I think this is one of them. it didn't scare me or amuse me or excite me. it did disgust me though. but you know, I can get disgusted by looking at a pile of vomit or shit. why would I want to do that? "disgust" in horror is one thing, an often valuable thing, an often important part of creating a feeling of horror, particularly body-based horror. but being disgusted just to be disgusted, for no other reason? that's not interesting to me. that's
being bored and disgusted at the same time is not a great feeling. and it is certainly not a feeling of being challenged. I would have liked to have been challenged. instead it was all just pointlessly repulsive. the attempts at humor were eye-rolling. why not just take a picture of a bucket of vomit or shit instead.
it is hard for me to understand the purpose of this endeavor. should the creation of simultaneous feelings of boredom and disgust be the goal of a writer - or any kind of artist?
I noticed Richard Laymon and Ed Lee mentioned somewhere on this book, as if Gargoyle Girls is a crazy combination of those writers. as if. Ed Lee can create disgust but he has a vision attached to that disgust; his horrific and hallucinatory panoramas are the disgusting visions of an actual artist. Richard Laymon can create an atmosphere of creepy sexual perversion; the thing is, Laymon knows how to actually create "an atmosphere". he is also a professional who knows a thing or two about building an exciting narrative. this book is no child of Laymon & Lee.
but there was something that did stand out. something extra special and extra repulsive.
one of the supporting characters is given a backstory involving his strong ability with numbers, his bright future, then a tragic accident, brain damage, a loss of his talent, a dwindling away of that bright future. sad, huh? it was an intriguing backstory - and certainly designed to create some sort of sympathy for the guy. a three-dimensional character of sorts! but as far as that goes, in a story like this one, I prefer the unreal cartoon characters of [b:The Sex Beast of Scurvy Island|10962533|The Sex Beast of Scurvy Island|Andersen Prunty|http://d202m5krfqbpi5.cloudfront.net/books/1327875422s/10962533.jpg|15880297]. why create a sympathetic backstory when your intent is to do absolutely nothing with that story, when you plan to visit the most repugnant and viciously sadistic of tortures on that character? not only do you want to disgust and bore me, apparently you want to depress me too. that's like pulling wings off of a fly, legs off of a spider. what's the point?
girlfriend,
the kids and the remaining pirate find a beautiful and mysterious island. and so our tale truly begins...
this book is vile. if you like vile, you should read this book. I highly recommend it!
if you like the human body - and other sorts of bodies - to be viewed as pieces of meat to be fucked with, carcasses-to-be, then this is also your book. have fun with it!
there are surely some books that get written just to see if they could, well, be written. not to play with language or share ideas or tell a good story or scare you or amuse you or excite you or take you to a different place. books that exist just because. I haven't come across many books like that but I think this is one of them. it didn't scare me or amuse me or excite me. it did disgust me though. but you know, I can get disgusted by looking at a pile of vomit or shit. why would I want to do that? "disgust" in horror is one thing, an often valuable thing, an often important part of creating a feeling of horror, particularly body-based horror. but being disgusted just to be disgusted, for no other reason? that's not interesting to me. that's
being bored and disgusted at the same time is not a great feeling. and it is certainly not a feeling of being challenged. I would have liked to have been challenged. instead it was all just pointlessly repulsive. the attempts at humor were eye-rolling. why not just take a picture of a bucket of vomit or shit instead.
it is hard for me to understand the purpose of this endeavor. should the creation of simultaneous feelings of boredom and disgust be the goal of a writer - or any kind of artist?
I noticed Richard Laymon and Ed Lee mentioned somewhere on this book, as if Gargoyle Girls is a crazy combination of those writers. as if. Ed Lee can create disgust but he has a vision attached to that disgust; his horrific and hallucinatory panoramas are the disgusting visions of an actual artist. Richard Laymon can create an atmosphere of creepy sexual perversion; the thing is, Laymon knows how to actually create "an atmosphere". he is also a professional who knows a thing or two about building an exciting narrative. this book is no child of Laymon & Lee.
but there was something that did stand out. something extra special and extra repulsive.
one of the supporting characters is given a backstory involving his strong ability with numbers, his bright future, then a tragic accident, brain damage, a loss of his talent, a dwindling away of that bright future. sad, huh? it was an intriguing backstory - and certainly designed to create some sort of sympathy for the guy. a three-dimensional character of sorts! but as far as that goes, in a story like this one, I prefer the unreal cartoon characters of [b:The Sex Beast of Scurvy Island|10962533|The Sex Beast of Scurvy Island|Andersen Prunty|http://d202m5krfqbpi5.cloudfront.net/books/1327875422s/10962533.jpg|15880297]. why create a sympathetic backstory when your intent is to do absolutely nothing with that story, when you plan to visit the most repugnant and viciously sadistic of tortures on that character? not only do you want to disgust and bore me, apparently you want to depress me too. that's like pulling wings off of a fly, legs off of a spider. what's the point?
girlfriend,